About Us

  • The Mitchell Insurance Agency has been a family-owned and operated business since 1961. We provide insurance for your business and personal needs. We pride ourselves on providing excellent service to our clients including annual review of their insurance policies. The Mitchell Agency represents 42 insurance companies to serve your insurance needs. We offer insurance in New Jersey, Pennsylvania and New York. At the Mitchell Insurance Agency, we believe the best source for your insurance is an independent agent. We will provide someone with the integrity and professionalism who takes the time to learn about your specific needs and create the best possible insurance program and price that will be valuable to you. The Mitchell Agency is proud to announce it has received the "Best Insurance Agency of the Year" of Sussex County award for the third year in a row from the NJ Herald.

Experience & Reliability

  • Family Owned & Operated
  • In Business Since: 1961
  • Insured
  • Licensed
  • References Available
  • Years of Experience: 50

Hours

  • Evening & Weekend Appointments

Services

    • Phone Quotes
  • Agent for: Loss Control, Risk Management, Advisory , Home Owners Insurance, Auto Insurance, Small Business, Directors Officers, Professional Liability, Cyber Liability Insurance, Health Insurance, Employment practice liability, workers comp, business auto, personal umbrella, business umbrella insurance, e&o Insurance, Fire Insurance, Lessor's Risk, ERISA Bonds, Key Man Insurance, Buy Sell Agreements, Life Insurance, Employee Benefits, Bond's, Risk Seminars, Employee Safety Programs, Employee Handbooks, Crime Insurance, Property Insurance, Plus many more!
  • Boat Insurance
  • Business Insurance
  • Health Insurance
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Immediate Insurance Coverage
  • Independent Insurance Agent
  • Life Insurance
  • Low Down Payments
  • Multi Policy Discounts
  • Notary Public on Site

Discounts

  • $25.00 gas card for any referral that leads to closed business.

Payment

  • Personal Checks